Book Reviews Other Reviews

Review: Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Good Bye: Part #4

All images are © 2014 Dark Horse Books / Frank Miller, All opinions are my own.


Previously, we covered Part 3 of The Hard Goodbye. Now, we have a continuation with Part 4.

WARNING: This book most certainly is NSFW and only for adults. I will do my best to leave the vulgarities out of it so that everyone can enjoy. Although, if you can stomach the madness to achieve the full effect, a proper purchase of the source materials is recommended.

WARNING: Spoilers ahead: In depth review including respectable, occasional snaps of the art work and surrounding thoughts.

Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Goodbye: Part 4

Part 4 of The Hard Goodbye starts off with a some memories of a friend named Chuck that was retarded, but Marv loved him because he was “dumb enough to think he was a genius” and he compares those memories with his current dilemmas.

“I’ve been framed for murder and the cops are in on it. But the real enemy, the son of a bitch who killed the angel lying next to me, he’s out there somewhere, out of sight, the big missing piece that’ll give me the how and the why and a face and a name and a soul to send screaming into hell.”

He continues with details of a plan based off the information his mother gave him about the previous visitors looking for him. His plan involves sending him, whoever it is, an invitation and if he doesn’t die in the process, he’ll get a couple more pieces that fit this puzzle.

Now, we have mention from Marv that you can find whatever you need down any back ally in Sin City and we are transitioned into a scene where Marv talks about a bar named Kadie’s and this information is layered with details about how anything that’s worth doing in Sin City is illegal and messed up. He gets free drinks at Kadie’s for favors. One of the workers at Kadie’s is someone named Nancy that likes to shake it to good, old country music:

First mention of a character named Nancy

Nancy is a dancer at the bar Kadie’s with a lasso and an attached cowboy hat. Marv normally just enjoys the dance, but not tonight. No, that’s not what he’s looking for. He picks a fight with someone named Weevil and slams his back out, tells him to spread the word and get some payment for it “because it’s worth it” and give the details about what to spread the word about: his grievance of Goldie. He orders a drink from a waitress named Shellie.

Nancy dances more and whips with her lasso.

Marv goes out back of Kadie’s and talks about how he loves hit men because no matter what you do to ’em, you don’t feel bad. “The worse you do, the better it gets.” Trouble is, they have him at gun point. Marv is making jokes about the guy’s jacket:

Marv puts up a strong fight and it the hit men, they brought coats to a gun fight. Marv takes one of their guns and wins, tells him to take his coat off because he is bleeding all over it:

Marv wins the fight out back of Kadie’s bar. Seems some hit men were trying to off him.

Marv tells the guy with the coat that it must have not been them that killed Goldie, but he interrogates the last man standing to find answers. The man tells him it was Telly Stern that gave the orders and Telly runs the tables over at The Triple Ace Club. Marv kills the man he is interrogating and tells him thank you.

Marv has olfactory hallucinations about Goldie and claims he only needs his medicine. Then, we see a woman peering around the corner:

Mysterious woman peers around the corner after Marv’s fight with hit men out back of Kadie’s.

Marv realizes the sun is coming up and needs to find a place to rest, although he was “just getting warmed up”.

My Thoughts:

Marv likes old, good solid country music. Good on him! He’s not into the feel good, happy music. He more enjoys what feels genuine to him and not washed up. He is taking no safe paths here, only looking to set an example for his quest to find out who is behind framing him for Goldie’s murder.

I didn’t mention this at all last time, but it’s obvious that Marv is just out of prison, with his discussions with Lucille and I’m nervous for the path that he is on. Just can’t catch a break!

Marv has connections in his town, again with women. I’ve yet to see any man friends or people he is getting along with that are of his same gender. Hrm. Marv has characteristics of being intelligent and brutish.

We don’t learn much in this chapter besides mystery. He claims to know the dancer Nancy, but there’s no interaction with her, only fighting and a mysterious woman that peers around the corner after his fight with the hit men. I can’t help but notice that she looks like Goldie and Weevil looks like . . . Wolverine from Marvel comics? Ha, ha! Geez.

Who is this mysterious woman? Who is Telly Stern?

See you next time,

Guys and gals, until next time – may you find all the happiness that your life can fit in it’s happy spot – S.D. McKinley.

By S.D. McKinley

S.D. McKinley lives in the suburbs of Atlanta, Georgia. He was born in the first half of the 1980's and grew up in Wisconsin as a young boy, then moved to Georgia when he turned exactly twelve years old. During teenage years, he raced dirt track go karts and played guitar. He discovered his current love for all kinds of art after his mid-life crisis at 25 years old. S.D. McKinley began writing books in 2017.

7 replies on “Review: Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Good Bye: Part #4”

I’m going to act like I haven’t seen the movie and play dumb. But even so, I’ll give a hint that’s probably not much good: it’s someone that looks like the late Goldie!

I borrowed a handful of these graphic novels from the library. Each book had the name of one of the chapters in the image of the content list. I guess the publisher put out smaller books for the series. Anyway, I really enjoyed them. Cool stories and really dramatic artwork. So damn good.

Leave a Reply to S.D. McKinley Cancel reply