Book Reviews Other Reviews

Review: Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Good Bye: Part #7 and #8

All images are © 2014 Dark Horse Books / Frank Miller, All opinions are my own.


Previously, we covered Part 5 and 6 of The Hard Goodbye. Now, we have a continuation with Part #7 and #8

WARNING: This book most certainly is NSFW and only for adults. I will do my best to leave the vulgarities out of it so that everyone can enjoy. Although, if you can stomach the madness to achieve the full effect, a proper purchase of the source materials is recommended.

WARNING: Spoilers ahead: In depth review including respectable, occasional snaps of the art work and surrounding thoughts.

Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Goodbye: Part 7

Part number seven starts out at the farm we were introduced from part six, where Marv and Lucille are still trapped in the tiled basement. Marv’s efforts to break free aren’t working, at least so far.

Marv trying to escape the basement.

Finally Marv knocks down the door and they are free. Marv makes a mental note that Lucille almost seems scared to leave. A helicopter approaches. It’s the police! Marv finds his gun ( sweet Gladys ) and cocks it. The police exit the helicopter, but don’t see Marv and Lucille.

Sweet “Gladys”, the gun.
The police, stepping off of the helicopter.

Marv tells Lucille the police are done checking the house, but are coming their way and he says “I’ll show them . . .” Lucille tells the police not to shoot Marv and then he grabs the axe out of the stump to bring it to the gun fight, with the cops.

He takes out all the cops except for the one with the mark on his face. Marv tells the cop that he has a nice coat on.

Marv chases the police officer with the mark on his face with the hatchet and laughing at the same time.

Lucille is dead with the cops.

Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Goodbye: Part 8


Marv talks about Sin City’s relation to rain and it barely rains most of the time, but sometimes a torrential down pour comes from the desert. Marv likes the rain, it helps him think things through, helps him look at the big picture. He is on alert for more cops. He thinks of what the preacher told him, the name “Roark”.

Every part of him wants to escape his troubles and just run away. He tells himself “I’m as good as dead”. He claims to himself that he is no hero, but he just can’t let Goldie go and he is more scared of dying than living now. He reasons with himself that Goldie knew her life was in danger and that’s why she hooked up with Marv. He feels bad for letting her die in his drunken stupor.

We learn that the “Roark” family has owned Sin City for a long time. Marv wants to kill Patrick Henry Roark. He shoots into the distance.

Finally, he questions himself that he could be wrong about the whole thing. He gets confused and with Lucille dead, he can’t get his medicine now. He tells himself he may be imagining things. Has he turned into a maniac killer? What everyone said that he would?

So, he is going to do something to make sure he is headed in the right direction. He is going to “Old Town” that is alive and bustling by the time he arrives. Old Town was made like it is with lots of dirty business by Roark’s grandfather. Marv asks around about Goldie. There is hookers in old town, so he should be able to find some things out. He sees the mysterious woman that looks just like Goldie and she shoots Marv and the bullet clips his head.

Now Marv is tied to a chair.

One of the other women calls the person that looks like Goldie, they call her “Wendy” and tell her to hit him again. Marv calls her Goldie. Marv questions why someone called her Goldie. Wendy tells Marv that Goldie is her sister. The women think that Marv is lying about Goldie and they think that Marv killed her. He defends himself with talk.

The women that Marv ends up with in Old Town Sin City.

The women level with him and now believe that Marv didn’t kill Goldie.

My Thoughts:

I can’t believe it took Marv this long to question his actions. Wow. I mean, you are avenging the death of someone you just met. Ridiculous. What is the chance that Wendy is lying and she is really Goldie and they have set Marv up? This is muddy, for sure.

Now that he has someone of use on his side, namely Goldie’s. The way the women from Old Town Sin City just start to believe Marv, that transition in the story was a bit cheesy, seemed unnatural, but I think that comes with the territory on this dark comic omnibus.

Let’s see what happens next time after Marv has found and leveled with Goldie’s sister . . .

Guys and gals, until next time – may you find all the happiness that your life can fit in it’s happy spot – S.D. McKinley.

By S.D. McKinley

S.D. McKinley lives in the suburbs of Atlanta, Georgia. He was born in the first half of the 1980's and grew up in Wisconsin as a young boy, then moved to Georgia when he turned exactly twelve years old. During teenage years, he raced dirt track go karts and played guitar. He discovered his current love for all kinds of art after his mid-life crisis at 25 years old. S.D. McKinley began writing books in 2017.

6 replies on “Review: Big Damn Sin City: The Hard Good Bye: Part #7 and #8”

Spark the Camp 🔥: